Jacob Sneed
← All writing

Displacement and the Right to Education

Responsibilities, Rights, and Resources: A Literature Review

A review of the literature on refugee education organized around three questions: why education is a human right, who is responsible for providing it to displaced people, and how the resources to deliver it can be found.

In the first decades of the 21st century, the numbers of each category of forced migration, including internal displacement, asylum seekers, and refugees, have increased significantly to record-breaking levels. According to the United Nations High Council for Refugees (UNHCR, 2024), at the end of 2023 there were at least 117 million forcibly displaced people, 47 million of whom are children. Overlapping drivers of displacement such as conflict, ethnic violence, an increase in climate change induced extreme weather events, and economic and political fragility in an increasingly interconnected and globalized world have compounded to cause a surge in dislocation that is overwhelming international response systems. The danger and disruption of forced displacement has outsized consequences for children and young people. Estimations of the average length of dislocation are between 10-26 years, which means many displaced children spend their entire childhood away from their homes and some may never return (Ferris, 2018).

Education rights for children and young people and the rights of displaced persons to education are enshrined in the foundational documents of Intergovernmental Organizations (IGOs) such as the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) and the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees. In 1993 the Vienna Declaration established Human Rights Education (HRE) as important to encouraging awareness of and respect for human rights. HRE has since attempted to bridge a gap between socio-legal human rights instruments and rights theory, and the practice and implementation of human rights (Bajaj & Mabona, 2021). More recently, members of the international community have reasserted their commitment to educating displaced people through the 2024 INEE Minimum Standards, the Education Cannot Wait funding initiative in 2016, and including refugee education as a priority in the 2018 Global Compact for Refugees. However, school enrollment for young refugees is far below international norms at 68% enrollment for primary school, just 37% of school-aged children attending secondary school, and only 6% of refugees are enrolled in higher education (Bullard & Jalbout, 2022). A woeful lack of data on the rates of education for school-aged internally displaced children means it is difficult to assess how internal dislocation affects the quality of and access to education for displaced children who have not crossed an international border. However, “most internally displaced children live in countries with some of the largest disparities in access to education and lowest outcomes in the world” shaped by a range of factors that include gender, socioeconomic status etc., as well as displacement (Cazabat & Yasukawa, 2022).

This lack of data on access to the right of education for IDPs and the unprecedented surge in cross-border displacement so far in the 21st century highlight the pressing need for an updated assessment of our collective understanding at the nexus of human rights education, displacement, and human rights. This literature review organizes contemporary findings on HRE, and displacement into three conceptual categories of examination: the right to education, the responsibilities for delivering this right, and the development and distribution of resources necessary to satisfy the education needs of a diverse and vulnerable population of people.

Methodology

The focus of this literature review is to examine contemporary scholarship that links the underlying theories of human rights and HRE to the practice of educating displaced persons. This review will examine the interconnectedness of human rights values and norms as they relate to the field of dislocation response and education. The goal of the analysis is to acquire insight into why there are such low rates of education enrollment among refugees and probe the sociopolitical conditions that allow for the current dearth of data on IDP education. This literature review relies on Cooper’s Taxonomy of Literature Reviews as a framework to examine a “purposive sample” of foundational, secondary source materials from 1990 to 2024 that includes material from peer-reviewed journals, monographs as well as research and policy reports from Intergovernmental Organizations (IGOs), NGOs, and national governments (Randolph, 2007, p. 4). The broad selection of source material reflects the diverse stakeholders who are engaged in the provision of education for and to displaced persons. Key word searches were conducted on Google Scholar and the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign Library Search using the terms human rights and education, displacement and education, refugees and education, and human rights education and displacement.

Limitations

This literature review is not exhaustive. Its brevity requires a distinct focus that limits the ability to provide the nuance and descriptive account that such a complex set of issues would require in a comprehensive review. Yet, succinctness also requires the subject-area expertise necessary to do the difficult work of culling inessential works to produce the most pertinent review of the available literature. The literature reviewed is exclusively in the English language, another limitation in a field that’s concerns span the globe.

The reviewer is educated in the Western academic traditions, which may produce biases favoring the universalist conception of human rights that was developed in the aftermath of WWII and historically has skewed rights issues towards western-centric perspectives. Despite these limitations, this review is grounded in thorough research and analysis producing a strong confidence in its validity and usefulness to anyone working on or researching issues at the nexus of human rights, human rights education, and displacement.

Literature Review

Rights – Why is Education a Human Right?

Article 26 of the UNDHR states that, “Everyone has the right to education” forming the basis of contemporary conceptualizations of education as an indelible right (United Nations, 1948, Article 26). The Article details a framework for interpreting and applying education as a right in three core areas of concern that remains relevant today:

  1. Everyone has the right to education. Education shall be free, at least in the elementary and fundamental stages. Elementary education shall be compulsory. Technical and professional education shall be made generally available and higher education shall be equally accessible to all on the basis of merit.

  2. Education shall be directed to the full development of the human personality and to the strengthening of respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms. It shall promote understanding, tolerance and friendship among all nations, racial or religious groups, and shall further the activities of the United Nations for the maintenance of peace.

  3. Parents have a prior right to choose the kind of education that shall be given to their children. (United Nations, 1948, Article 26)

However, in “Reframing the universal right to education” Dr. Tristan McCowen (2010) argues that the UNDHR, while formative and important to enshrining the right to education, has important shortcomings that have yet to be adequately addressed in the subsequent covenants, conventions, and international agreements that have modified it since. According to McCowen (2010, p. 4) three elements of Article 26 of the UDHR undermine its purpose including, “the identification of education with schooling; the restriction of the absolute right to the elementary level; and the lack of discussion of the forms taken by education”. Furthermore, the UDHR says too little about what the aims of education should be, excepting the assertion that “education shall be directed to the full development of the human personality” which McCowen asserts is the only case in which the individual, rather than society are the benefactors of education (United Nations, 1948, Article 26). Instead, McCowen (2010, p. 15) proposes a conceptualization of the right to education as such:

  1. The right to engage in educational processes that are both intrinsically and instrumentally valuable, and that embody respect for human rights.

  2. The right of access to educational institutions and experiences that confer positional advantage.

In this alternative view, McCowen asserts the importance of an expanded view of education beyond schooling, and throughout a lifetime, rather than only primary education. As well, the right to an education, and institutions that grant positional advantage, is important to addressing the role of education as a social leveling mechanism that can undermine systemic oppressions. Although not specifically mentioned, the forcibly displaced represent a chronically disadvantaged group for which education should work to advance positional advantage from the significant challenges of refugee camps, statelessness, and other positions of disadvantage.

The idea of education as a method of eliminating disadvantages also undergirds Spring’s 2000 monograph The Universal Right to Education: justification, definition, and guidelines which applies a specific focus to the right to education for cultural minorities. Spring asserts that in an emerging global culture, a primary justification for the right to education is that, “that all people have the right to an education that provides them with the ability and understanding to determine the advantages and disadvantages of the global economy and culture” which, importantly grants them “the power to mediate the relation between their own cultures and the current world system” (Spring, 2000, p. 18). For displaced persons, the power to navigate the current world system devoid of access to education is nearly impossible. In circumstances that are defined by a complex arrangement of international and domestic law, political agreements enforced by increasingly securitized means displaced persons are often the victims of this system and represent a diverse but distinctly oppressed group that are routinely denied access to rights.

Responsibilities – Who is Responsible for Providing Education to Displaced Persons

In the context of displacement, education rights are often undelivered. According to Tomaševski (2001, p. 8) because “the right to education is routinely classified as an economic, social and cultural right” which lacks clear solutions consequently “denials and violations of the right to education are not addressed”. Tomaševski influential 4A conceptual framework outlines education rights in two principal components that both include two sub-components firstly the right to education defined as availability and access and rights in education which she defines as acceptability and accessibility. Critically, Tomaševski (2001, p. 8) identifies governments as the primary responsible agent for delivering education rights stating, “The conceptual counterpart of human rights are then governmental obligations. Governments are individually obliged to secure human rights for their own population”. However, governments are often incapable of providing basic services because of conflict, economic crisis, or extreme weather events and in some cases, governments are actively perpetrating human rights abuses. Within the 4A framework, the adaptability dimension is described as encompassing child migrants, without detailed whether migration is forced in the context of danger or voluntary, however identifying governments as the primarily responsible part for the education of children who leave who requires more insight in which governments and where.

Bullard and Jalbout (2022) provide some answers to these questions in the policy brief “Key Tensions in Refugee Education” by establishing the concept of inclusion as the primary strategy for delivery access to education for refugees. Importantly, refugee inclusion in national education systems moves beyond ensuring attendance and provides insight into how “classroom content, pedagogies, and interactions” can work to “make refugees feel supported, included, and connected to their identity, communities, and school culture” (Bullard & Jalbout, 2022, p. 4). Although Bullard and Jalbout agree with Tomaševski that state-led refugee education is the most effective model under current international refugee laws, and political agreements, they also recognize the role of non-state actors as important to filling in the gaps left by state initiatives that fail to meet a minimum standard of quality education. Bullard and Jalbout (2022) demonstrate the critical role of non-state initiatives working to supplement national education by highlighting, among others, Amala Education, an NGO that works across continents in refugee camps and urban settings offering an accredited high-school diploma program for students aged 16-25 who do not have access to a formal national school system. While programs like Amala Education are important to addressing the significant needs of displaced students and the lagging capacity for national education systems to deliver a quality education, the majority consensus among researchers is that national systems should shoulder the majority of responsibility. However, many st/ates do not have the necessary means or capacity to deliver a quality education to their own population and struggle to incorporate a large influx of displaced persons into their national education system. Most displaced people are in some of the poorest regions of the world. In the context of internal displacement Cazabat and Yasukawa (2022) argue that non-state humanitarian agencies and IGOs are essential to responding to displacement emergencies when state resources fail, however the medium to long-term goal of reintegrating internally displaced children into national education systems is fundamentally important to their ability to access the right to education. It is essential then to view responsibility, and resources as interdependent.

Resources – How Can the Necessary Resources to Fulfill the Right to Education be Delivered

Undisputedly, providing a quality education to displaced learners incurs significant costs. According to research conducted by the World Bank and UNHCR (2021, p. 10), “Eighty-five percent of the world’s displaced persons are hosted in low and lower middle-income countries” with limited financial means to provide for both IDP populations and refugees. Although, “In theory refugee law creates an absolutely uniform distribution of responsibility: all states have to admit refugees onto their territory” and utilize the resources at their disposal to deliver to refugees a standard of living that upholds their human rights including access to education, in practice states are better suited to approaching displacement support through the concept of comparative advantage and providing the resources they are best suited to (Betts & Collier, 2017, p. 208). Although some states like Japan admit very few refugees, as a wealthy nation they are able to and do provide sizable donations to refugee causes and in the view of Betts and Collier (2017) states should be held to a limited but meaningful baseline commitment in terms of refugee acceptance and financial contribution to displacement causes.

The need is vast. The same World Bank and UNHCR (2021) study previously mentioned estimates that the annual cost of providing a quality, inclusive education to refugee students in low, lower middle, and upper-middle income states is roughly US$4.85 billion. Bullard and Jalbout (2022) recognize financing long-term refugee education as a key concern within the issue-area wherein policymakers must transition from short term external financing towards long-term inclusion within national education systems. Inclusive refugee policies recognize the importance of reframing refugee inclusion as a net benefit to societies who, if enabled to participate in education and the economy, can ultimately be able to restore their autonomy.

In Teachers of Refugees: A Review of the Literature, Ericka Richardson (2018) establishes how refugee teachers, when empowered to take part in the workforce become a valuable asset to delivering the right to education because their unique language skills, cultural insight, and experiential knowledge with displacement positions them as potentially best suited to work with displaced learners from their country of origin. As Richardson (2018, p. 27-32) states, “the teacher is the most important in-school factor affecting the quality of education” however “depending on the national policies of the host country, refugee teachers may not have the right to work for a salary, or to work as a teacher in the public education system”. Excluding refugee teachers from workforce participation in host countries aligns with a broader pattern that Bullard and Jalbout (2022) describe as a deficit perspective which view refugees as a burden. Instead, their research posits that an asset perspective can reframe refugee issues by, “engaging closely with refugees to understand their cultures, hopes, and ideas and co-constructing programming and policy with refugees” through which displaced teachers and students “can access opportunities not only to learn and teach, but also to heal, see themselves reflected in the systems around them, feel included in their communities, and imagine a future for themselves” (Bullard & Jalbout, 2022, p. 28). Despite the reality that educating displaced persons is costly, it is an opportunity to prepare millions of students for a world in which they can be active participants and contributors.

Conclusion: The Importance of Further Research

Human displacement is one of the most pressing humanitarian crises of our time. A generation of young people who have fled perilous circumstances are attempting to rebuild their lives in locations of continued dangers and limited resources. The global human rights regime is validated by its capacity to ensure and deliver rights to the world's most vulnerable groups of people. If human rights are only accessible to the wealthy and privileged, they are meaningless. The right to education for displaced persons is critical to providing what McCowen (2010, p. 510) calls “positional advantage” in a competitive global society. This literature represents a small sample of some of the most important research conducted at the nexus of human rights, the right to education, and displacement. Although the scope of this review is limited further research into how the failure of international agreements and organizations as well as nation states have allowed the displacement crisis to reach unprecedented levels and continue to fail to deliver the right of education to millions of young learners.


References

Bajaj, M. & Mabona, N. (2021). Theories of Human Rights Education in Comparative and International Education. The Bloomsbury Handbook of Theory in Comparative and International Education, 361

Betts, A., & Collier, P. (2017). Refuge: Rethinking Refugee Policy in a Changing World. Oxford University Press.

Bullard, K., & Jalbout, M. (2022, November 16). Key tensions in refugee education. Brookings. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/key-tensions-in-refugee-education/

Cazabat, C., & Yasukawa, L. (2022). Informing Better access to education for IDPs. In IDMC - Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre. https://www.internal-displacement.org/publications/informing-better-access-to-education-for-idps/

Ferris, E. (2018, June 19). When refugee displacement drags on, is self-reliance the answer? Brookings. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/when-refugee-displacement-drags-on-is-self-reliance-the-answer/

McCowan, T. (2010). Reframing the universal right to education. Comparative Education, 46(4), 509–525. https://doi.org/10.1080/03050068.2010.519482

Randolph, J. (2007). A Guide to Writing the Dissertation Literature Review. Practical Assessment, Research, & Evaluation. 14.

Richardson, E. (2018). Teachers of Refugees: A Review of the Literature. Distributed by ERIC Clearinghouse.

Spring, J. H. (2000). The Universal Right to Education: justification, definition, and guidelines. http://ci.nii.ac.jp/ncid/BA47426495

Tomaševski, K. (2001d). Human rights obligations: Making Education Available, Accessible, Acceptable and Adaptable. Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency.

UNHCR. (2024). Refugee statistics. UNHCR - the UN Refugee Agency. https://www.unhcr.org/refugee-statistics/

United Nations. (1948). Universal declaration of human rights. https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-human-rights

World Bank & UNHCR. (2021). The Global Cost of Inclusive Refugee Education. Washington, DC: World Bank. https://documents.worldbank.org/en/publication/documentsreports/documentdetail/159281614191477048/the-global-cost-of-inclusive-refugeeeducation.

Lightly edited for the web from the original submission. Citations follow APA style.