A deal between two kings
NYU Abu Dhabi grew out of two sets of ambitions. John Sexton, then NYU's president, wanted to build a "global network university" with campuses embedded in strategic world cities, and Abu Dhabi was to be its flagship, with enormous financial backing behind it. For the emirate's rulers, led by Crown Prince Mohammed bin Zayed, hosting an elite Western university was part of a larger strategy to build soft power and diversify away from oil. The same Saadiyat Island development was planned to hold the Louvre Abu Dhabi and a Guggenheim.
"This is a deal between two kings: the emir of Abu Dhabi and the emir of NYU."NYU professor, as quoted in press coverage of the partnership
The two sides wanted different things from the same project. NYU sought to globalize its academic prestige, while Abu Dhabi sought influence and legitimacy on the world stage. The result was a university and an authoritarian state acting as co-investors in a project of mutual branding, at the expense of the workers who built it.
Timeline
- NYU issues its Statement of Labor Values for the Abu Dhabi project.
- Construction begins on the Saadiyat Island campus.
- Workers strike for better wages across Abu Dhabi and Dubai, including on Saadiyat Island.
- Hundreds of workers are deported after the strikes.
- NYU Abu Dhabi issues a statement on migrant labor conditions, citing a series of compliance reports.
- The New York Times reports exploitative labor conditions and deportations.
- Former President Bill Clinton addresses the first graduating class at the new campus.
Labor abuses at Saadiyat Island
Contractors building the campus were implicated in serious violations of NYU's own Statement of Labor Values. Many workers who went on strike were jailed, reported abuse in custody, and were deported. At the first commencement, Clinton acknowledged that the controversy had dominated coverage of the week and framed it as a chance to confront questions of equality and identity in concrete terms.
Internationalization of education
The NYU Abu Dhabi case shows the contradictions of neoliberal globalization, in which education is treated as a globally mobile commodity rather than a public good. Elite universities compete for prestige, capital, and influence, and they often align with authoritarian governments and private interests to fund ambitious expansion.
In theory, education is a great leveler across class, race, and nationality. On Saadiyat Island, students from around the world study in gleaming facilities meant to produce cosmopolitan leaders, while the migrant workers who built those facilities remain exploited and excluded. Global institutions can reinforce the inequalities they claim to reduce. NYU Abu Dhabi's vision of global transformation came at the cost of the human rights values it espouses.
Internationalization can entrench the current global class hierarchy, or it can work to take it apart. Global higher education can be a social equalizer only if institutions uphold labor rights, if expansion prioritizes inclusion over elite access, and if partnerships are transparent, accountable, and grounded in educational values as well as economic ones.
Discussion questions
- What role should higher education play in a globalizing world?
- Does education have a responsibility to reduce social, economic, and political inequalities, or to prepare elites for that role in their national contexts?
- Are human and labor rights still potent forces in the current global system, or have they been rendered irrelevant?
- Are we entering a post-neoliberal era? If so, how will the position of Western universities shift within the emerging world order?
Adapted from the original slides and speaker notes. Timeline drawn from NYU statements and New York Times reporting cited in the presentation.